Two winters ago I stood at the bathroom mirror at 6:40 in the morning, cotton pad in hand, and watched a waterproof mascara take three lashes with it. That was the week I stopped buying waterproof formulas for everyday wear. I am 48. The skin around my eyes is thinner than it was at 38, and the fine lines at the outer corners do not forgive much tugging. I moved to the MAYBELLINE Lash Sensational Sky High Washable Mascara and I have used it most weekdays and every Saturday for about seven months.
Two coats, a minute to set, and my normal evening face wash at the end of the day. That is the whole routine. Below are ten specific reasons this one has earned its place on my narrow bathroom shelf, and where it has annoyed me, because it has. I am not an esthetician and I am not going to tell you it repairs anything. It is mascara. But there is a real difference between a formula you have to scrub off and one that lets go when you ask it to, and past forty that difference matters more than anything printed on the tube.
The tube that comes off with your face wash, not against it
MAYBELLINE Lash Sensational Sky High Washable Mascara. Buildable, straight wand, full coverage on the first pass, and no pad held against your eye at ten at night.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →It lets go with the face wash you already own
I do not own an eye makeup remover. I have not bought one since I switched. At the end of the day I wet my face, use the same cleanser I always use, and the mascara comes away in the washcloth without a dedicated oil or a pad pressed against my eye for thirty seconds. That is the entire reason I started looking at washable formulas, and it is the reason I stayed. A plain night moisturizer follows and nothing more elaborate than that. The less time my hands spend near my lash line, the better my eyes look the next morning.
No scrubbing at the outer corners, where the fine lines sit
My fine lines started showing around my eyes in my early forties and they have not gone anywhere. The outer corners are where every waterproof mascara I have owned demanded the most work, and work is what stretches that skin. With this one I am not pressing a pad into the corner and counting to ten. I wash, I rinse, I look. If there is a trace left, a second pass of the washcloth gets it. Seven months of that and I have not created a new crease by trying to remove my makeup.
The straight wand reaches the inner lashes that clump first
The wand on this tube is straight, which sounds like nothing until you have spent years with a curved brush that misses the two or three shortest lashes near the tear duct. Those are the ones that clump and flake when they get over-coated, and they are also the ones that make a lash line look finished. The straight wand gets in there without me rolling my wrist at an awkward angle in the mirror. Small thing. It is the small things that decide whether I reach for a tube on a Tuesday morning.
Buildable means you can stop at two coats and mean it
The formula is buildable, and I take that literally. Two coats, and I stop. Add a third and I get clumping at the tips, which is the one complaint I will keep repeating. So I do not add a third. The good part is that two coats look deliberate rather than thin, which was not true of the lighter washable formulas I tried before this one. Knowing where to stop is half of wearing mascara at 48, and this tube makes the stopping point obvious.
Bamboo extract and fibers do the lengthening, not a second product
The MAYBELLINE listing names bamboo extract and fibers, and the fibers are what you can actually see working. They sit on the lash and add length at the tip. I do not own a lash primer and I am not going to start one now. One tube covers the lengthening, the volumizing and the defining, which matters when your shelf is one narrow plank beside a single sink. Anything that removes a step from a shared bathroom at 6:40 in the morning has already earned its space.
Full coverage on the first pass, so less back and forth
Coverage on the listing is full, and the first coat does most of the work. That means fewer passes over the same lashes, and fewer passes is the whole game when the skin under your eye is thin. I load the wand once, wiggle from the base, sweep up, and I am done with that eye. The second coat is for the outer half only. When I catch myself going back a fourth time out of habit, I put the wand down, because that is where smudging starts.
It says plainly that it is not water resistant, which I use
The water resistance level on this listing is not water resistant, and I like a product that tells me what it is instead of making me find out. I do not wear it to my Saturday Pilates class and I do not wear it on a hot walk with Pepper. I put it on afterwards. In exchange I get a formula that releases on contact with water and cleanser instead of holding on through both. That trade is the reason I can wear mascara on a weekday at all.
One 0.24 fluid ounce tube, replaced about every three months
The MAYBELLINE tube holds 0.24 fluid ounces and weighs 18.14 grams. That is a normal mascara size and it lasts me about three months of near daily use, which happens to be when a tube starts to dry and the wand starts dragging. I would rather buy a small tube four times a year than nurse a big one until it flakes. The packaging measures 0.85 by 2.75 by 5.63 inches, and it stands upright on my shelf without falling behind the toothpaste.
High pigment density means fewer passes over the same lash
Pigment density is listed as a special feature and it is the reason the first coat reads as a coat rather than a tint. I am not building depth with four thin layers, which is what I used to do with lighter formulas and which is exactly how the outer corners got irritated. One loaded pass, one clean pass, done. If you have ever finished your makeup and felt your eyes water from the effort of it, this is the part that changes.
It is listed for sensitive skin and it has behaved like it
Sensitive skin is the skin type on the listing, and I can only report my own experience, which is that my eyes have not stung or watered from the formula itself. I am a person who reacts to scented products, so I notice. It also comes off cleanly enough that I am not leaving residue along the lash line overnight, and residue is what usually sets my eyes off the next day. I am not a dermatologist. I am a woman of 48 with a mirror and a washcloth.
What I'd Skip
If you swim laps, if you teach a spin class, if you cry at weddings and expect your mascara to come out the other side, skip this one for that day and wear a waterproof formula instead. It is not water resistant and it does not pretend to be. I also would not buy it if you are a three coat person, because a third coat clumps, and I would not buy it if you want a formula that holds a hard curl through a hot afternoon, because that is not its job either. What it does is give you a full, lengthened lash line on an ordinary Tuesday and then let go of your lashes at ten at night without a fight. I compared it with the Lash Sensational formula in a separate piece if you want the side by side. For me the washable version is the one that stays, and I have replaced the tube twice.
Two coats, a straight wand, and a face wash at ten at night. Seven months in, that is still the whole routine, and the tube has never taken a lash with it.
If your lashes come out with the mascara, start here
MAYBELLINE Lash Sensational Sky High Washable Mascara, 0.24 fluid ounces, straight wand, buildable to two coats. It comes off with your normal evening face wash, not a separate remover.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →